Springfield South Dakota Veterans
  • World War I
    • Veteran Photos
    • Veteran Photos
    • Biographies >
      • Edwin Dwight Wood
  • World War II
    • The Rest of the Story >
      • Lawrence Namminga
      • Fred C Hornstra
      • Chuck Dawes
      • Grover DeLong
      • John Palsma
      • Clarence Ludens
      • Jack Martin
      • Bob Slade
      • Joe Uken Jr
    • Springfield Was There
    • Biographies A-H >
      • Walter Babcock
      • Wayne Barham
      • Charles "Chuck" Dawes
      • Grover DeLong
      • Jake DenOuden
      • Biographies K-Ma >
        • Bernard Kastein
        • James Kirk
        • Leonard Lange
        • Ted Lindeman
        • Clarence Ludens
        • John C. Ludens
        • John "Jack" Martin
        • Richard "Darby" Martin
      • Robert DeRoos
      • Shorty Halsey
      • Nanno Hiemstra
      • Fred C Hornstra
    • Biographies Mi-O >
      • Floyd Mitchell
      • Jacob Namminga
      • Lawrence Namminga Sr
      • Ode Odens
      • Lawrence Owens
    • Biographies P-S >
      • Allen Palsma
      • John Palsma
      • Virgil Rauch
      • Jack Rich
      • Robert Slade
    • Biographies Th-U >
      • Clark Thomas
      • Neil Thomas
      • Merle Toyne
      • Joe Uken
  • Korean War
    • Veteran Photos
    • The Rest of the Story >
      • Robert "Bob" Ludens
    • Biographies >
      • Donald Dempster
      • Gelvin "Gil" DeRoos
      • Robert "Bob" Ludens
      • Virginia McClure
      • Donald McMillan
      • Peter Monfore
      • Wilbert Renner
      • Clarence Vanderlei
  • Cold War
    • Veteran Photos
    • Biographies >
      • Robert McCollum
  • Vietnam War
    • Veteran Photos
    • The Rest of the Story >
      • Daryl Heusinkveld
      • Harvey Kastein
      • Dan Mejstrik
      • Lee Merchen
      • Larry Talsma
    • My Week in Hue City
    • Biographies >
      • Daryl Heusinkveld
      • Harvey Kastein
      • Perry Lundin
      • Dan Mejstrik
      • Lee Merchen
      • Robert Monfore
      • Larry Talsma
  • Middle East Wars
    • Veteran Photos
    • Biographies >
      • James "Uke" Uken
  • Army National Guard
    • Veteran Photos
    • Rapid City Flood
    • Japanese Internment

Do Renewable Energy Sources Have a Place in Our Military?

11/15/2020

0 Comments

 
Picture
By Dick Martin

I usually limit our Sunday Features to military related topics.  Renewable energy resources, ie. Wind and Solar are not by themselves military topics, but the military’s deep direct reliance on energy require that if they want to continue to be a world power and affect the future of the world , they have to always be aware of the energy component of any decisions that they make.   Personally, I don’t feel that I know enough about reliable renewable energy sources to have any firm opinions.  I do know that:

  1. The sun does not always shine and wind does not always blow.
  2. Wind and solar combined provide only about 4% of our energy needs.
  3. Probably not in our lifetime, we will run out of fossil fuels.
  4. Compared to fossil fuels, at this point in time, renewable energy is cost prohibitive.
  5. Since we do know that we will run out of carbon energy sources; in the meantime, it seems prudent for us to continue to develop renewable energy sources so we will be ready for that date.

Recently, I was talking to John Hollman about this topic, and he directed me to an article on the subject titled “Mines, Minerals, and “Green” Energy” authored by  Mark P Mills, who is an senior fellow at the Manhattan Institute and a faculty fellow of Northwestern University’s McCormick School of Engineering and Applied Science.  The following is an edited summary of his article: 

Among the material realities of green energy are:


  1. Building wind turbines and solar panels to generate electricity requires, on average, more than ten times the quantity of materials, compared with building machines using hydrocarbons to deliver the same amount of energy;
  2. A single electric car contains more cobalt than 1000 smartphone batteries, and the blades on a single wind turbine have more plastic than 5 million smartphones;
  3. Replacing hydrocarbons with green machines will vastly increase the mining of various critical minerals; ie., a single electric car battery weighing 1000 pounds requires extracting and processing some 500,000 pounds of materials.  All energy-producing machinery must be fabricated from material extracted from the earth.  Compared with hydrocarbons, green machines entail, on average, a 10-fold increase in the quantities of materials extracted and processed to produce the same amount of energy;
  4. Oil, natural gas and coal are needed to produce the concrete, steel, plastics and purified minerals used to build green machines.  The energy equivalent of 100 barrels of oil are used in the processes to fabricate a single battery that can store the equivalent of one barrel of oil;
  5. By 2050, the quantity of worn out solar panels will constitute double the tonnage of all of today’s global plastic waste, and by 2030, more than 10 million tons per year of batteries will become garbage.
  6. Left out of current discussions is any serious consideration of the broad environmental and supply-chain implications of renewable energy.  Any significant expansion of today’s level of green energy--currently less than 4% of the country’s total consumption (versus 56% from oil and gas) will create an unprecedented increase in global mining for needed minerals.  Imports make up 100% of some 17 key minerals and for another 29, over half of domestic needs are imported.
  7. Replacing the energy output from a single 100 MW natural gas-fired turbine, requires at least 20 wind turbines, each one about the size of the Washington Monument.  Building those wind machines consumes enormous quantities of conventional materials; ie., about 30,000 tons of iron ore and 50,000 tons of concrete and 900 tons of non-recyclable plastics.
  8. Recycling plays a role in providing all of the materials necessary for the construction and running of renewable energy machines, but the idea of a green energy circular economy based on the goal of 100% recycling is a pipe dream.

Theoretically, we will eventually run out of fossil energy.  This would make us a second-rate military power.  All of the above problems are daunting, but my experience in the oil industry is that the US companies are able to solve or mitigate the above problems to a manageable level.  The oil industry is capable of solving many complex problems, as long as there is an incentive to do so. 

“Where there is a will, there is a way.”



0 Comments

    Categories

    All
    Arlis Namminga Wozniak
    Bernard Kastein
    Carol Hagen
    Carol Wysuph
    Charlene Dempster
    Clarence Vanderlei
    Dale Ludens
    Dan Mejstrik
    Daryl Heusinkveld
    David Lange
    David Odens
    Dick Martin
    Donald McMillan
    Doug Hanify
    Eugene Hornstra
    Gary Romkema
    Gene Lang
    Gil DeRoos
    Glenda Palsma Meech
    Jim Hornstra
    Jim Kirk
    Jim Uken
    Jon Mitchell
    Joyce Romkema
    Julie Hanisch
    Larry Lang
    Laura Martin
    Lawrence Namminga
    Lee Merchen
    Lee Morton
    Linda Rauch Scott
    Linda Tjeerdsma
    Lori Slade Krier
    Loyal Meech
    Marilyn Thomas Stone
    Mary Monfore Hurd
    Merle Toyne
    Nancy McMillan Flammang
    Perry Lundin
    Ronnie Hornstra
    Sandy Uken Haima
    Springfield Veterans
    Tim Diede
    Virgil Rauch
    Wilbert Renner

    Archives

    December 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017

This web page is a work in progress. It has been created through the donated efforts of Laura Genant Martin, Dick Martin, and Jim Hornstra. When Laura was made aware of what we needed, she took the initiative to research and educate herself on how to create a web site to identify, respect and honor the military veterans in Springfield. The web site had to be easy to navigate and had to provide the viewer a method of providing feedback. Most of the written material has been provided by Dick Martin over the past couple of years with some important contributions from others, i.e. Jim Kirk.  Jim Hornstra has been the reliable source as he has been the collector of information concerning Springfield Veterans and has provided Laura much of what has gone into the web site.
  • World War I
    • Veteran Photos
    • Veteran Photos
    • Biographies >
      • Edwin Dwight Wood
  • World War II
    • The Rest of the Story >
      • Lawrence Namminga
      • Fred C Hornstra
      • Chuck Dawes
      • Grover DeLong
      • John Palsma
      • Clarence Ludens
      • Jack Martin
      • Bob Slade
      • Joe Uken Jr
    • Springfield Was There
    • Biographies A-H >
      • Walter Babcock
      • Wayne Barham
      • Charles "Chuck" Dawes
      • Grover DeLong
      • Jake DenOuden
      • Biographies K-Ma >
        • Bernard Kastein
        • James Kirk
        • Leonard Lange
        • Ted Lindeman
        • Clarence Ludens
        • John C. Ludens
        • John "Jack" Martin
        • Richard "Darby" Martin
      • Robert DeRoos
      • Shorty Halsey
      • Nanno Hiemstra
      • Fred C Hornstra
    • Biographies Mi-O >
      • Floyd Mitchell
      • Jacob Namminga
      • Lawrence Namminga Sr
      • Ode Odens
      • Lawrence Owens
    • Biographies P-S >
      • Allen Palsma
      • John Palsma
      • Virgil Rauch
      • Jack Rich
      • Robert Slade
    • Biographies Th-U >
      • Clark Thomas
      • Neil Thomas
      • Merle Toyne
      • Joe Uken
  • Korean War
    • Veteran Photos
    • The Rest of the Story >
      • Robert "Bob" Ludens
    • Biographies >
      • Donald Dempster
      • Gelvin "Gil" DeRoos
      • Robert "Bob" Ludens
      • Virginia McClure
      • Donald McMillan
      • Peter Monfore
      • Wilbert Renner
      • Clarence Vanderlei
  • Cold War
    • Veteran Photos
    • Biographies >
      • Robert McCollum
  • Vietnam War
    • Veteran Photos
    • The Rest of the Story >
      • Daryl Heusinkveld
      • Harvey Kastein
      • Dan Mejstrik
      • Lee Merchen
      • Larry Talsma
    • My Week in Hue City
    • Biographies >
      • Daryl Heusinkveld
      • Harvey Kastein
      • Perry Lundin
      • Dan Mejstrik
      • Lee Merchen
      • Robert Monfore
      • Larry Talsma
  • Middle East Wars
    • Veteran Photos
    • Biographies >
      • James "Uke" Uken
  • Army National Guard
    • Veteran Photos
    • Rapid City Flood
    • Japanese Internment