Springfield South Dakota Veterans
  • World War I
    • Veteran Photos
    • Veteran Photos
    • Biographies >
      • Edwin Dwight Wood
  • World War II
    • The Rest of the Story >
      • Lawrence Namminga
      • Fred C Hornstra
      • Chuck Dawes
      • Grover DeLong
      • John Palsma
      • Clarence Ludens
      • Jack Martin
      • Bob Slade
      • Joe Uken Jr
    • Springfield Was There
    • Biographies A-H >
      • Walter Babcock
      • Wayne Barham
      • Charles "Chuck" Dawes
      • Grover DeLong
      • Jake DenOuden
      • Biographies K-Ma >
        • Bernard Kastein
        • James Kirk
        • Leonard Lange
        • Ted Lindeman
        • Clarence Ludens
        • John C. Ludens
        • John "Jack" Martin
        • Richard "Darby" Martin
      • Robert DeRoos
      • Shorty Halsey
      • Nanno Hiemstra
      • Fred C Hornstra
    • Biographies Mi-O >
      • Floyd Mitchell
      • Jacob Namminga
      • Lawrence Namminga Sr
      • Ode Odens
      • Lawrence Owens
    • Biographies P-S >
      • Allen Palsma
      • John Palsma
      • Virgil Rauch
      • Jack Rich
      • Robert Slade
    • Biographies Th-U >
      • Clark Thomas
      • Neil Thomas
      • Merle Toyne
      • Joe Uken
  • Korean War
    • Veteran Photos
    • The Rest of the Story >
      • Robert "Bob" Ludens
    • Biographies >
      • Donald Dempster
      • Gelvin "Gil" DeRoos
      • Robert "Bob" Ludens
      • Virginia McClure
      • Donald McMillan
      • Peter Monfore
      • Wilbert Renner
      • Clarence Vanderlei
  • Cold War
    • Veteran Photos
    • Biographies >
      • Robert McCollum
  • Vietnam War
    • Veteran Photos
    • The Rest of the Story >
      • Daryl Heusinkveld
      • Harvey Kastein
      • Dan Mejstrik
      • Lee Merchen
      • Larry Talsma
    • My Week in Hue City
    • Biographies >
      • Daryl Heusinkveld
      • Harvey Kastein
      • Perry Lundin
      • Dan Mejstrik
      • Lee Merchen
      • Robert Monfore
      • Larry Talsma
  • Middle East Wars
    • Veteran Photos
    • Biographies >
      • James "Uke" Uken
  • Army National Guard
    • Veteran Photos
    • Rapid City Flood
    • Japanese Internment

2016 MEMORIAL DAY ADDRESS

11/26/2017

1 Comment

 
By Dick Martin
Picture
Today is a day to honor all of those soldiers who have made the ultimate sacrifice.  All of those veterans are special and have been duly honored over the years.  I have spent hours writing their stories and honoring them as best I could.
  
About 15 years ago, I was talking to a Springfield local, Bob Coleman, about the different wars, and he talked about the Korean War as his war.  He did not mean his own personal war, but his generation’s war.  For my generation, it was the Vietnam War.  It was an ambiguous war that hung over the heads of my generation during our youth.   Without forgetting any of those from all wars who have given their lives, today, I would like to pay a special tribute to the Vietnam veterans who gave their lives in service to our country and to all those who answered the call and served in the controversial war in Southeast Asia. 
 
Those who spent significant time in the bush can astound us with the personal measures they had to take to survive and function in the hellish weather and terrain conditions they encountered in Vietnam.  Some came home to verbal and physical abuse and all came home to indifference and lack of gratitude from the American public for their service.   
  
Most have probably long ago closed the book on the Vietnam War.  I have never been able to do that.  Today, for just a few minutes, so that we can properly appreciate and honor our Vietnam veterans, I would like to ask you to reopen that book and let me take you back to the situation in the world at that time, and our response to it.   At that time, I had no clue about American foreign policy, so my opinion was knee-jerk patriotism.  I was not obsessed with the war but it was always at the back of my mind as I read history of the war and what lead us to get involved.  Gradually, over about 30 years of research, I was able to draw some conclusions.  Contrary to what the general consensus is, I learned there were very good reasons why we got involved.  I think my conclusions stand up to scrutiny.  However, as you recall, there was plenty of controversy back then, so don’t be surprised if you disagree with me.   
 
The Vietnam War took place long ago in a far-off land.   More than any other war, the Vietnam War was questioned as to whether or not it was justified.  At that time, except for believing Communism to be bad, I had no idea what the prevailing thinking was, what it was based on, and why we got involved.   After years of reading plenty about that era and the times leading up to it, I determined that the decisions to get us involved were based on logical and rational assumptions arrived at from easily observable actions and statements from the Communist world.  Unfortunately, despite a plethora of evidence to validate those assumptions leading up to the war, as the war progressed and in subsequent years, they proved to be false, giving rise to the argument that our involvement in Vietnam was a costly mistake.  To be specific, I see two main assumptions that drove us to our involvement in Southeast Asia: 

  1.  The first assumption by our leaders was that Communism was monolithic, bent on spreading throughout the world.  This assumption was clearly stated in the book “The Communist Manifesto” written by German Communists Karl Marx and Friedrich Engels.  By monolithic, it is meant that Communism will spread as one unified common force from country to country, ending as one Communism throughout the world, directed by a central authority, probably in the USSR.  Did you ever see the 1950s movie “The Blob” starring Steve McQueen.  Think of monolithic Communism as the blob growing bigger and stronger as it swallowed more people in the case of the blob and more countries in the case of Communism.  The infamous “Domino Theory” of that time originated from this line of thinking. 
  2. The other assumption was that Ho Chi Minh, the acknowledged Vietnam leader at that time, was Communist above all else.  (The Burns documentary disputes this and claims that the much more militant Le Duan was the leader at that time pushing Ho and his allies aside.  For the purposes of prevailing thinking, it really does not matter who the leader was, only that we thought he was Communist.)  This assumption is easily arrived at by tracing Ho’s activities, education, and affiliations in France and Vietnam before the war.  

In short, what we were looking at was an aggressive Communist North threatening the non-communist South lead by a leader indoctrinated in the Communist ideology bent on spreading throughout the world, or so we thought.   Consequently, US policy was solidly committed to stopping the spread of Communism as evidenced by the United States’ participation in preventive measures such as the following: 

  1.  Truman doctrine – Based on the first assumption, President Truman drew a line around the existing Communist world and said “No More;” 
  2.  SEATO – To draw Truman’s line we signed two treaties: NATO in Europe and SEATO in Southeast Asia, that included South Vietnam as a protectorate; and 
  3. Korean War – We enforced the Truman doctrine in Korea, successfully stopping Communism at the cost of over 37,000 Americans killed.  

In order to avoid involvement in Vietnam when the Communist threat developed there in the 1950s and 1960s, the decision makers would have had to ignore the well-justified assumptions that Communism was monolithic with the goal of taking over the world, and that Ho Chi Minh had substantial ties to Communism.  In addition, they would have had to ignore the Truman Doctrine, violate the SEATO treaty, and blow off the 37,000 Americans killed in Korea successfully stopping the spread of Communism there.  
 
With all of that making up the prevailing thinking, we were committed to enforcing the Truman Doctrine, honoring our membership in SEATO and employing the methods that worked in Korea.  The loss in credibility, sustained by the United States by abdicating those responsibilities, would have had far-reaching and long-lasting effects on its standing and foreign policy in the world.    
After the war, the validity of the assumptions began to fade.  Ultimately, Ho Chi Minh proved he was a nationalist first, and a Communist a distant second.  Stalin’s death ended any thoughts of a monolithic Communism taking over the world.  Mao used that opportunity to break with Khruschev and the USSR resulting in China’s dangerous confrontations in competition with the USSR and backing the opposite side in regional wars involving client states of the USSR and China. With both of our assumptions losing steam, Vietnam, today, is, in many respects, better than we could have hoped for and certainly no monolithic threat to the world. 
 
Three years ago, I toured Vietnam and was overwhelmed by the peaceful hustle and bustle of free enterprise thriving everywhere.  Adam Smith and Milton Friedman, noted free enterprise economists, would be very happy with the strides the country has made since the war. 
  
For all of those who have examined Communism and Ho Chi Minh after the war and discovered Communism far from monolithic and Ho Chi Minh mainly a nationalist rather than Communist; and therefore, boldly conclude that our involvement in the Vietnam War unnecessary, I would say “Hold the Phone.” That is not how it works.  You don’t get to make decisions based on conditions that appear years later.  You have to make them based on the current situation.
     
Our military is a very important leg of our foreign policy.  It has no value if it has no legitimacy.  Its legitimacy comes from its professionalism, and the men and women who make up its ranks.  Due to the dedication and service of those who served in Vietnam, our military has been able to maintain its legitimacy and it continues to do so today as a supremely important leg of our foreign policy.    With those thoughts as a backdrop, I would like to give a special salute to all of those who made the ultimate sacrifice or served in Southeast Asia and were so important in maintaining the legitimacy of the military leg of our foreign policy.  For the rest of the Springfield Veterans who served or gave their lives for our country, I salute them too and will do my best to continue to recognize them by telling their story.  

Finally, I would like to say how proud I am of all of the Springfield Veterans who served their country no matter what war they served in.


1 Comment
Cayden Haas link
1/4/2024 11:24:42

Helloo mate nice blog

Reply



Leave a Reply.

    Categories

    All
    Arlis Namminga Wozniak
    Bernard Kastein
    Carol Hagen
    Carol Wysuph
    Charlene Dempster
    Clarence Vanderlei
    Dale Ludens
    Dan Mejstrik
    Daryl Heusinkveld
    David Lange
    David Odens
    Dick Martin
    Donald McMillan
    Doug Hanify
    Eugene Hornstra
    Gary Romkema
    Gene Lang
    Gil DeRoos
    Glenda Palsma Meech
    Jim Hornstra
    Jim Kirk
    Jim Uken
    Jon Mitchell
    Joyce Romkema
    Julie Hanisch
    Larry Lang
    Laura Martin
    Lawrence Namminga
    Lee Merchen
    Lee Morton
    Linda Rauch Scott
    Linda Tjeerdsma
    Lori Slade Krier
    Loyal Meech
    Marilyn Thomas Stone
    Mary Monfore Hurd
    Merle Toyne
    Nancy McMillan Flammang
    Perry Lundin
    Ronnie Hornstra
    Sandy Uken Haima
    Springfield Veterans
    Tim Diede
    Virgil Rauch
    Wilbert Renner

    Archives

    October 2023
    May 2023
    April 2023
    March 2023
    January 2023
    December 2022
    January 2022
    December 2021
    November 2021
    October 2021
    September 2021
    August 2021
    July 2021
    June 2021
    May 2021
    April 2021
    March 2021
    February 2021
    January 2021
    December 2020
    November 2020
    October 2020
    September 2020
    August 2020
    July 2020
    June 2020
    May 2020
    April 2020
    March 2020
    February 2020
    January 2020
    December 2019
    November 2019
    October 2019
    September 2019
    August 2019
    July 2019
    June 2019
    May 2019
    April 2019
    March 2019
    February 2019
    January 2019
    December 2018
    November 2018
    October 2018
    September 2018
    August 2018
    July 2018
    June 2018
    May 2018
    April 2018
    March 2018
    February 2018
    January 2018
    December 2017
    November 2017
    October 2017
    September 2017
    August 2017
    July 2017
    June 2017
    May 2017
    April 2017

This web page is a work in progress. It has been created through the donated efforts of Laura Genant Martin, Dick Martin, and Jim Hornstra. When Laura was made aware of what we needed, she took the initiative to research and educate herself on how to create a web site to identify, respect and honor the military veterans in Springfield. The web site had to be easy to navigate and had to provide the viewer a method of providing feedback. Most of the written material has been provided by Dick Martin over the past couple of years with some important contributions from others, i.e. Jim Kirk.  Jim Hornstra has been the reliable source as he has been the collector of information concerning Springfield Veterans and has provided Laura much of what has gone into the web site.
  • World War I
    • Veteran Photos
    • Veteran Photos
    • Biographies >
      • Edwin Dwight Wood
  • World War II
    • The Rest of the Story >
      • Lawrence Namminga
      • Fred C Hornstra
      • Chuck Dawes
      • Grover DeLong
      • John Palsma
      • Clarence Ludens
      • Jack Martin
      • Bob Slade
      • Joe Uken Jr
    • Springfield Was There
    • Biographies A-H >
      • Walter Babcock
      • Wayne Barham
      • Charles "Chuck" Dawes
      • Grover DeLong
      • Jake DenOuden
      • Biographies K-Ma >
        • Bernard Kastein
        • James Kirk
        • Leonard Lange
        • Ted Lindeman
        • Clarence Ludens
        • John C. Ludens
        • John "Jack" Martin
        • Richard "Darby" Martin
      • Robert DeRoos
      • Shorty Halsey
      • Nanno Hiemstra
      • Fred C Hornstra
    • Biographies Mi-O >
      • Floyd Mitchell
      • Jacob Namminga
      • Lawrence Namminga Sr
      • Ode Odens
      • Lawrence Owens
    • Biographies P-S >
      • Allen Palsma
      • John Palsma
      • Virgil Rauch
      • Jack Rich
      • Robert Slade
    • Biographies Th-U >
      • Clark Thomas
      • Neil Thomas
      • Merle Toyne
      • Joe Uken
  • Korean War
    • Veteran Photos
    • The Rest of the Story >
      • Robert "Bob" Ludens
    • Biographies >
      • Donald Dempster
      • Gelvin "Gil" DeRoos
      • Robert "Bob" Ludens
      • Virginia McClure
      • Donald McMillan
      • Peter Monfore
      • Wilbert Renner
      • Clarence Vanderlei
  • Cold War
    • Veteran Photos
    • Biographies >
      • Robert McCollum
  • Vietnam War
    • Veteran Photos
    • The Rest of the Story >
      • Daryl Heusinkveld
      • Harvey Kastein
      • Dan Mejstrik
      • Lee Merchen
      • Larry Talsma
    • My Week in Hue City
    • Biographies >
      • Daryl Heusinkveld
      • Harvey Kastein
      • Perry Lundin
      • Dan Mejstrik
      • Lee Merchen
      • Robert Monfore
      • Larry Talsma
  • Middle East Wars
    • Veteran Photos
    • Biographies >
      • James "Uke" Uken
  • Army National Guard
    • Veteran Photos
    • Rapid City Flood
    • Japanese Internment